14 Best Restaurants in Paia Maui (2023)

Located along Maui’s pristine North Shore, Paia is a charming town that beckons travelers with its laid-back atmosphere and vibrant cultural tapestry.

Beyond its stunning beaches and bohemian ambiance, Paia boasts a culinary scene that’s as diverse as the island’s landscapes.

From quaint local eateries to upscale seafood restaurants, this charming town has something for every palate.

As we step into 2023, the purpose of this blog post is to be your guide to the finest dining experiences in Paia.

Join us on a flavorful journey as we explore the top restaurants in Paia, revealing the culinary treasures that await your visit in this tropical paradise.

Whether you’re seeking a great place for a relaxed meal, hoping to catch a delightful happy hour, or simply looking for an unforgettable dining experience, Paia restaurants, including the ever-popular Rock & Brews, have it all.

These favorite places bring you the best meals, crafted with fresh, local ingredients, ensuring a great experience that captures the essence of Paia’s vibrant culinary culture.

1. Honolua Store

Tucked in the heart of Paia, the Honolua Store is more than just a restaurant; it’s a slice of local history and a culinary gem that has stood the test of time.

This charming establishment has roots that trace back to the early 1920s when it served as a general store for the local plantation community.

Today, it offers a fusion of old-world charm and modern culinary delight.

As you step inside, you’re transported to a bygone era, with vintage décor and an inviting ambiance that beckons you to linger.

Honolua Store is renowned for its menu, which features a delectable array of dishes made from fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

From their famous “Honolua Club Sandwich” to mouthwatering poke bowls, there’s something for everyone.

Customer reviews consistently highlight the store’s warm, welcoming atmosphere and the genuine hospitality of the staff.

For an authentic taste of Paia and a slice of its history, Honolua Store is a must-visit, and it comes highly recommended by both locals and visitors alike.

2. Mama’s Fish House

A legendary establishment nestled on the shores of Paia, Maui, needs no introduction to seasoned travelers.

With a reputation that precedes itself, this oceanfront gem has long been a symbol of fine dining and island hospitality.

What truly sets Mama’s Fish House apart is its unwavering commitment to sustainable practices, serving seafood that is not only incredibly fresh but also ethically sourced.

Every visit here is a celebration of Hawaii’s aquatic bounty, where you can savor signature dishes like the Tahitian Ceviche, prepared with the catch of the day.

Their cocktails, featuring tropical ingredients and top-shelf spirits, are an absolute delight.

However, securing a reservation at Mama’s can be a challenge, so we’ll also provide you with some valuable tips on how to plan your visit and ensure an unforgettable dining experience by the tranquil waves of the Pacific Ocean.

3. Flatbread Company

Nestled amidst the lush, laid-back streets of Paia is the ever-charming Flatbread Company.

This local gem has made its name by offering a truly unique pizza experience.

What sets Flatbread Company apart is its commitment to using organic ingredients sourced from local farmers, resulting in a farm-to-table journey that tantalizes your taste buds.

Their specialty pizzas are nothing short of masterpieces, featuring a medley of fresh, vibrant toppings that showcase the best flavors of the island.

But the magic doesn’t stop there; Flatbread Company takes inclusivity seriously, offering an array of gluten-free and vegan options that don’t compromise on taste.

As you dine, you’ll not only savor delectable pizzas but also a warm, welcoming atmosphere infused with community spirit.

The cozy ambiance and frequent live music performances make it a perfect spot to unwind after a day of exploring Paia’s treasures.

Flatbread Company is a culinary experience that’s as wholesome as it is delicious, and a must-visit for all pizza enthusiasts and those seeking a slice of Paia’s local charm.

4. Paia Fish Market

Located in the heart of Paia, the Paia Fish Market offers a casual dining experience that captures the essence of this beach town’s laid-back vibe.

With its rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere, it’s the kind of place where sandy toes and salty hair are not only welcomed but celebrated.

But what truly sets Paia Fish Market apart is its commitment to freshness.

The menu showcases an array of fresh fish and seafood options, often sourced locally, ensuring that every bite bursts with the flavors of the ocean.

If you’re in the mood for customization, their build-your-own fish tacos and sandwiches allow you to craft your ideal seafood delight, tailored to your exact preferences.

While it’s easy to assume that quality comes at a premium, the Paia Fish Market manages to maintain an authentic local vibe without breaking the bank.

This combination of delectable offerings and affordability makes it a must-visit spot for anyone looking to savor the true flavors of Paia without emptying their wallet.

5. Nuka Sushi

Nuka Sushi, a true gem in Paia’s culinary crown, is the brainchild of a sushi master whose dedication to the art of sushi is palpable in every bite.

With an unerring commitment to the freshest ingredients, Nuka’s sushi rolls are a work of art, a perfect fusion of freshness and creativity.

Expect your taste buds to be tantalized by innovative combinations and beautifully crafted presentations that redefine the sushi experience.

Nuka doesn’t just excel in sushi; their sake and beverage selection is also a testament to their dedication to delivering an all-encompassing Japanese culinary adventure.

For those eager to savor this culinary delight, reservations are strongly recommended.

Dining at Nuka is not just a meal; it’s an experience that will immerse you in a world of flavors, culture, and artistry, making it an essential stop on your Paia culinary journey.

6. Cafe Des Amis

Nestled at the heart of Paia, Cafe Des Amis is a true culinary gem, enticing diners with its global-inspired cuisine.

With a menu as diverse as the cultures it draws inspiration from, this café offers a delightful fusion of flavors.

From savory crepes that transport you to the streets of France to rich and aromatic Indian dishes that awaken your senses, Cafe Des Amis has something to satisfy every craving.

What truly sets this establishment apart is its enchanting garden setting, where diners can bask in the tropical ambiance while enjoying live music in the background.

And for those with dietary preferences, Cafe Des Amis caters to all, with an array of vegetarian and vegan-friendly options that are as flavorful as they are satisfying.

Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner under the stars or a casual lunch with friends, Cafe Des Amis promises a memorable dining experience in the heart of Paia.

7. Mana Foods

When you’re seeking a break from restaurant dining but still want to savor the finest local flavors, look no further than Mana Foods.

This health-conscious haven in Paia offers a unique and delectable experience.

Mana Foods, a beloved institution among both residents and visitors, is renowned for its commitment to quality and nourishment.

With an abundance of organic and locally sourced produce, Mana Foods allows you to assemble your perfect picnic or beachside feast.

Their prepared foods section presents an array of tempting salads, hot dishes, and delectable treats, making it a go-to destination for those in need of a quick, wholesome meal.

For the health-conscious, their smoothie bar offers a delightful selection of nutrient-packed beverages.

Whether you’re a dedicated vegan, a clean eater, or simply looking for an easy, tasty meal, Mana Foods has you covered with its diverse menu and grab-and-go options, ensuring that you can savor the tastes of Maui wherever your adventure takes you.

8. Charley’s Restaurant & Saloon

Charley’s Restaurant & Saloon exudes a rustic charm that harks back to its rich history.

Originally established in 1969, this iconic establishment has been a gathering place for locals and tourists alike.

Known for its warm and welcoming ambiance, Charley’s boasts a lively atmosphere that perfectly complements its hearty American cuisine.

The menu at Charley’s features a mouthwatering array of dishes, from juicy burgers and succulent ribs to fresh salads and sandwiches.

However, the true showstoppers are their renowned breakfast offerings, with fluffy pancakes and creative omelets stealing the spotlight.

As you dine amidst the lively saloon atmosphere, you’ll often hear the sounds of local musicians, adding a distinctive touch to your dining experience.

With its long-standing tradition and a loyal following, Charley’s comes highly recommended for those seeking a taste of Paia’s history and a hearty meal in a friendly, welcoming setting.

9. Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop

In the heart of Paia, Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop is a charming culinary gem that combines the warmth of a local kitchen with the craftsmanship of a world-class bakery.

This quaint eatery boasts a delightful assortment of hand-crafted pies and a menu that celebrates the flavors of Maui.

While they’re renowned for their delectable pies, like the iconic Olowalu Lime or the irresistible Banana Cream, Leoda’s offers a full menu with savory options as well.

Must-try dishes include their mouthwatering sandwiches, fresh salads, and innovative farm-to-table creations.

Pair your meal with their house-made drinks, such as the Lilikoi (passion fruit) iced tea.

The dining experience at Leoda’s is one of casual comfort, where you can enjoy your meal inside the cozy, rustic interior or take a seat on the porch to savor your food amidst the pleasant Maui weather.

Reservations aren’t typically required for this casual and welcoming establishment, making it a perfect spot for a spontaneous dining experience in the heart of Paia.

10. Milagros Food Company

Milagros Food Company stands as a culinary gem known for its vibrant Latin-inspired flavors and welcoming atmosphere.

With a menu that’s a fusion of Mexican, Caribbean, and Pacific Rim cuisines, Milagros offers a diverse selection of dishes.

Whether you’re a carnivore or a vegetarian, gluten-free or vegan, there’s something for everyone here.

From sizzling fajitas to mouthwatering seafood ceviche, the culinary highlights at Milagros Food Company promise a symphony of tastes and aromas that will transport your palate to far-off tropical destinations.

Conveniently located along the Hana Highway, Milagros is easily accessible, making it an ideal choice for a delicious meal while exploring the charming town of Paia and its surrounding attractions.

11. Maui, Rock & Brews

Rock & Brews is a culinary gem that combines rock ‘n’ roll vibes with delicious cuisine.

This restaurant was founded with a passion for music, great food, and a welcoming atmosphere.

The history of Rock & Brews is a testament to the love of rock music, featuring an impressive collection of rock memorabilia that adorns its walls.

The menu at Rock & Brews boasts a delectable selection of American classics with a creative twist, from mouthwatering burgers to hearty sandwiches and finger-licking appetizers.

But what truly sets this place apart is its extensive craft beer selection, perfect for those looking to enjoy a brew with their meal.

The atmosphere here is electric, with live music often gracing the stage, creating a lively and entertaining experience.

Customer reviews frequently praise Rock & Brews for its rock-themed decor, friendly staff, and the perfect combination of rock music and culinary delights, making it a must-visit destination for those looking to dine and rock out in Paia.

12. Hali’imaile General Store

Nestled in the lush surroundings of Upcountry Maui, the Hali’imaile General Store is a culinary gem with a rich history and a reputation for excellence.

Originally a plantation store, it has been transformed into a delightful restaurant that exudes charm and a commitment to Hawaiian flavors.

The Hali’imaile General Store is the brainchild of renowned chef Beverly Gannon, who has crafted a menu that marries traditional Hawaiian ingredients with contemporary culinary techniques.

Guests are treated to an array of delectable dishes that highlight the island’s freshest ingredients, including locally caught fish, tender Maui beef, and exotic tropical fruits.

Among the specialties, the seared mahi-mahi with pineapple chutney and the Upcountry salad with goat cheese stand out as must-try items.

The restaurant’s ambiance is as inviting as its menu, with a rustic yet elegant décor that captures the spirit of Maui. Patrons often rave about the warm and attentive service, making the Hali’imaile General Store a perfect spot for both intimate dinners and celebratory gatherings.

If you’re seeking a memorable dining experience that blends tradition and innovation, this charming restaurant in the heart of Upcountry Maui should be at the top of your culinary itinerary.

13. Kula Lodge

Tucked high in the upcountry of Maui, Kula Lodge is a serene and rustic haven that offers a unique dining experience against the backdrop of stunning panoramic views.

Kula Lodge has been a beloved establishment in Maui since it opened its doors, serving locals and tourists alike for years.

The restaurant specializes in a delectable fusion of Hawaiian and American cuisine, emphasizing locally sourced ingredients to create dishes that reflect the island’s rich culinary heritage.

Among the standout menu items are their signature grilled mahi mahi, showcasing the freshest catch of the day, and their renowned lavender scones that infuse a touch of Maui’s fragrant lavender fields into a traditional delight.

Kula Lodge’s charming log cabin-style setting, surrounded by lush gardens and the majestic Haleakalā Crater in the distance, provides a warm and inviting ambiance.

Patrons frequently praise the lodge’s friendly staff, cozy fireplace, and, of course, the breathtaking sunset views from the terrace.

It’s a dining experience that perfectly marries the beauty of Maui’s landscapes with its local flavors, making Kula Lodge a must-visit destination for those seeking a taste of paradise.

14. Paia Bay Coffee

Nestled within the heart of Paia town, Paia Bay Coffee is a quaint and cozy coffee shop that holds a special place in the hearts of locals and tourists alike.

Founded with a passion for serving exceptional coffee, this establishment has become a beloved cornerstone of the community.

The backstory of Paia Bay Coffee is one that reflects a commitment to quality and sustainability; they source their beans from local Maui farmers and roast them in-house for the freshest brews.

Their menu brims with a variety of coffee delights, from expertly crafted espresso drinks to meticulously brewed pour-overs, catering to every coffee connoisseur’s preference.

Not to be missed are their unique Hawaiian-inspired specialties, such as the ‘Maui Mocha,’ a rich blend of Hawaiian chocolate and espresso.

The ambiance of Paia Bay Coffee is cozy and inviting, with an outdoor patio offering a perfect spot to enjoy your cup of java while soaking in the warm Hawaiian sun.

Patron recommendations often highlight the friendly and knowledgeable baristas who provide impeccable service, as well as the relaxed atmosphere that makes it an ideal place to start your day in Paia.

Whether you’re in the mood for a leisurely morning coffee or a quick pick-me-up on the go, Paia Bay Coffee delivers an authentic and delightful coffee experience in the heart of Maui’s North Shore.

Insider Tips

When embarking on your gastronomic adventure through Paia, there are some insider tips that can enhance your dining experience and help you discover the best places to eat.

First and foremost, consider making reservations, especially if you plan to visit popular restaurants during peak dining hours.

Paia’s dining spots can get crowded quickly, and having a reservation can save you from long waits and ensure that you enjoy great service.

Additionally, don’t miss the chance to savor some of the local food specialties such as fresh poke bowls, macadamia nut-crusted mahi-mahi, caught by local fishermen, and taro root dishes that offer a true taste of Maui.

To make your dining journey hassle-free, take note of parking and transportation recommendations. Paia can get busy, so knowing where to park and how to get around efficiently can save you time and frustration.

Lastly, after you’ve sampled the restaurants on our list, consider exploring additional hidden gems in Paia to further tantalize your taste buds and uncover the culinary secrets this vibrant town has to offer.

In the heart of Maui’s North Shore, Paia beckons with its enchanting blend of bohemian charm and culinary treasures, making it an exceptional destination for food enthusiasts.

As we wrap up our culinary journey, we’ve explored the best restaurants in Paia, Maui in 2023, offering a diverse array of flavors and experiences.

From the exquisite mahi mahi dishes at Mama’s Fish House to the global-inspired delights at Cafe Des Amis, and the local favorites at Paia Fish Market, this town offers a culinary spectrum that’s truly exceptional.

Paia, situated on the windward side of the island, invites you not just to dine but to immerse yourself in a unique culinary experience where the aloha spirit meets gourmet creativity.

With each bite, you’ll discover the rich tapestry of flavors that define this vibrant town, leaving you with a taste of the true essence of Maui.

Rock & Brews, with its star rating and reputation for providing a great experience, is the perfect place for those seeking a taste of rock ‘n’ roll vibes alongside delicious Hawaiian food.

We encourage our readers to savor the local flavors, book reservations in advance, and explore the hidden gems for a memorable culinary adventure on their next visit to Paia.

Whether you’re coming from the nearby town of Hana or all the way from the bustling West Maui, Paia promises some of the best things for your taste buds in 2023.